How to use
- Under common assumptions, enter your starting cash, how many years to compare and the yearly return on leftover cash. All three options start from the same cash.
- Under buy, enter the price, mortgage, rate, one-off acquisition and agent costs, yearly upkeep, home price growth and selling cost.
- Under jeonse, enter the deposit, jeonse loan and rate and the yearly deposit increase. Under monthly rent, enter the deposit, the rent and its yearly increase.
- The result shows which option leaves the highest net worth after N years, the housing cost of each and a year-by-year path. Use the unit checkbox to enter amounts in units of 10,000.
How it is calculated
To compare the three on the same footing, the tool compares net worth after N years: leftover cash plus the value of the home or deposit, minus debt. Interest, rent and upkeep all come out of cash, and leftover cash grows at your investment return.
| Option | Cash spent up front | Paid each year | Asset after N years |
|---|---|---|---|
| Buy | price − mortgage + acquisition and agent costs | loan interest + home value × upkeep rate | price × (1 + growth)^N × (1 − selling cost) |
| Jeonse | deposit − jeonse loan | loan interest + deposit increase at renewal | the increased deposit |
| Monthly rent | rent deposit | rent × 12 (rising yearly) | rent deposit |
Loans are simplified as interest-only with the principal repaid at the end. If the up-front money exceeds your cash, the gap is assumed borrowed at the same rate as your investment return, and a notice is shown.
Example
Starting cash 350,000,000, a 10-year comparison and a 3.5% return on leftover cash. Buying a 500,000,000 home with a 200,000,000 loan at 4%, 1% one-off costs, 0.3% yearly upkeep, 2% yearly price growth and 0.5% selling cost. Jeonse at 350,000,000 with a 50,000,000 loan at 4% and a 2% yearly deposit increase. Monthly rent with a 30,000,000 deposit, 1,000,000 a month and a 3% yearly increase. All amounts are in Korean won.
| Option | Net worth after 10 years | Housing cost over the period |
|---|---|---|
| Buy | about 356,920,000 | about 96,420,000 |
| Jeonse | about 334,300,000 | about 20,000,000 |
| Monthly rent | about 321,350,000 | about 137,570,000 |
Changing only the home price growth flips the result under the same inputs.
| Annual home price growth | Net worth if you buy, after 10 years | Best option |
|---|---|---|
| 0% | about 249,530,000 | jeonse |
| about 1.61% | equal to jeonse | buy and jeonse tie |
| 2% | about 356,920,000 | buy |
| 4% | about 485,150,000 | buy |
With 5 years instead, buying gives about 351,470,000, jeonse about 346,070,000 and monthly rent about 341,870,000, so the gap narrows. The biggest drivers of the answer are price growth, interest rates and how long you stay.
What it leaves out
- Taxes: capital gains tax, holding taxes and acquisition tax reliefs or surcharges must be entered by you. Put them into the one-off and upkeep fields, or check with the capital gains tax calculator and the acquisition tax calculator.
- Borrowing limits: how much you can borrow depends on income and rules. Check with the DSR and LTV calculator first.
- Amortization: this is an interest-only model, so cash flow differs from a loan repaid in instalments. See the monthly payment in the mortgage calculator.
- Converting jeonse and rent: use the jeonse to monthly rent converter.
- What numbers miss: the comfort of not having to move, the risk of not getting a deposit back, agent fees and subscription chances are not counted.
This is not investment advice, and results depend on assumptions. Home prices, rates and rents do not change at a constant rate, so treat the numbers as a guide.
FAQ
Which is better: jeonse, monthly rent or buying?
It depends, and none always wins. When prices barely rise or rates are high, jeonse or rent tends to do better; when prices rise enough, buying does. This tool shows where that line falls for the numbers you enter.
What home price growth should I enter?
There is no right answer. Try 0%, 2% and 4% and see where the result flips. Differences by region and period are very large.
If rent is higher than mortgage interest, am I losing?
Not necessarily. Buying ties up a lump sum and also carries price swings and upkeep. Compare net worth, as this tool does, rather than interest against rent.
How is an option with too little cash handled?
The shortfall is assumed borrowed at the same rate as your investment return. Real loan terms can differ, so read the notice on screen.
Related tools
Jeonse to monthly rent converter · Mortgage calculator · Korean acquisition tax calculator · Realtor commission calculator · DSR and LTV calculator
Your inputs are processed only in your browser and are never sent to a server.